Showing posts with label highcourt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label highcourt. Show all posts

High court grants compensation of Rs. 8 lakh to tea vendor

Granting some relief to a Burail tea vendor who lost his son by drowning in a pond at a park in Sector 33 in 2005, the Punjab and Haryana high court has directed the Chandigarh administration to pay him a compensation of Rs. 8 lakh. The directions came from the court headed by justice Ritu Bahri on a petition filed by Rattan Chand, father of the deceased master Pawan Kumar.

On August 3, 2005, his son, a Class-9 student, was returning home from Government Higher Secondary School, Sector-32, when he slipped into the pond and died on the spot.

“Therefore, the necessary conclusion is that after making a pond in the park, it was the duty of the administration to post police officials for monitoring, so as to prevent such kind of incident,” said justice Bahri.

The court has directed the administration to pay compensation to the petitioner within four weeks and to send the compliance report to the court.

The father had approached the high court seeking compensation, alleging that the officers had not properly maintained the park, resulting in a big low-lying area, which ultimately got converted into a pond in the rainy season in which his son drowned.

Appearing for the petitioner, senior advocate Satya Pal Jain argued that it was due to the gross negligence on the part of officials in the administration that they did not maintain the low-lying area, which ultimately got converted into a pond in the rainy season.

Jain had informed the court that deceased’s father was a tea seller on a footpath in Burail and had two sons and two daughters to feed. However, the UT administration had paid him a meagre amount of Rs. 20,000 as compensation. This was spent on the last rites.

Courtesy: Hindustan Times
Read More...

2 petitions against liquor bottles labels

Two writ petitions have been filed in the Hyderabad high court challenging the circulars issued by the governments of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh calling upon the distilleries to install the required hardware and software in their units for affixation of Holographic Excise Adhesive Labels (HEALs) on liquor bottles.

The association of liquor and beer suppliers, in its petitions, said that the distillery units were told to install the required hardware by May 30, 2014. It further stated that only HEALs would be used from July 1 onwards. A representation was made to the authorities explaining the difficulties faced by the distilleries in installing the hardware.

"Procuring hardware for affixation of HEALs is an expensive affair, with the distilleries having to bear high cost which will, in turn, adversely affect their business and consequently the industry in general. Members of the association could not procure the requisite hardware and have been manually affixing HEALs to the bottles from July 1 onwards," it explained.

The petitioner requested the authorities to exempt them from purchase and installation of the said equipment. Principal secretaries and commissioners of prohibition and excise, managing directors of beverages corporation limited of Telangana and AP states were named as the respondents.


Finding fault with the attitude of the Chief Executive Officer of Khammam Zilla Parishad in interfering with the possession and enjoyment of a private land, Justice MS Ramachandra Rao of the Hyderabad High Court directed the official to pay Rs 15, 000 costs to the petitioners for causing mental agony to them.

The facts of the case are that Dr. B. Nagesawara Rao and Dr. B. Sridevi moved the High Court in 2013 challenging the action of the authorities in interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of house plot situated at Khammam. They said that the land was purchased in 1981 and it is in their possession.

The ZP authorities have contended that the land actually belonging to the government and it was acquired to construct quarters for ZP staff.

As the authorities raised objection against possession and their owner ship of the land, the petitioners approached the government and a survey was conducted and found that the subject land is outside the land acquired for the in 1966.

The petitioners told the court despite of the survey findings, the ZP authorities decided to construct a compound wall on their land and damaged the fencing.

After verifying the records, the judge concluded that the action of the authorities arbitrary, mala fide and with improper motives and cannot be countenanced.

While allowing the writ petition, the judge directed the respondents to restrain from interfering with the possession and enjoyment of the subject land.

Courtesy: Times of India
Read More...

Techie death: Andhra Pradesh chief justice’s intervention nails friends

HYDERABAD: Six months after two software professionals died in a car accident in Kukatpally, the Cyberabad police told the high court that they already filed a chargesheet against the vehicle owner and another person (both friends of the deceased) for trying to hoodwink the cops by saying that one of the victim was driving the car at the time of accident.

Admitting that the intervention of chief justice Kalyan Jyoti Sengupta resulted in nabbing the real culprits, Cyberabad police commissioner C V Anand told the court that they had also arrested the car owner, Soumyajit Basu, in the case. The road accident occurred on March 1 this year.

The car had rammed into a tree near the KPHB junction at 3 am after the driver lost control of the vehicle.

Initially, Basu, who was at the wheel at the time of the accident, had forced his friend Neeladri (who as also in the car) to put the blame on Sudip Ghosh, one of the deceased, in their statement to the police.

Basu had even maintained that he was not in the car on that fateful night. The FIR too was registered that way and the police initially believed the theory floated by Soumyajit.

But as luck would have it, chief justice Sengupta received a letter sometime back from Dr Sujit Mukherjee, a professor from Kolkata, whose son Uttiya Mukherjee too died in this accident, describing how Sudip Ghosh was framed.

Chief justice on frequent holidays, traffic curbs

Expressing displeasure over frequent government holidays and traffic blockades in the city, Hyderabad high court chief justice Kalyan Jyoti Sengupta on Monday summoned top officials and ticked off the government for its failure to provide hassle-free roads to its citizens.Unhappy with traffic curbs in the city on account of Ganesh idols immersion on Monday, the chief justice, along with Justice P V Sanjay Kumar, hauled up advocate general K Ramakrishna Reddy the minute he urged the court to hear to an "urgent" appeal by the Jawaharlal Nehru Technological University against a single judge order. "You (Telangana government) declared a holiday today on one hand and want urgent matters to be heard at the same time," said a fuming justice Sengupta. Hassle-free roads: P5 The CJ converted this letter into a public interest litigation and directed the Cyberabad police chief to probe the case and submit a status report to court. Accordingly , police chief C VAnand filed a report on Monday stating that they had filed chargesheets against Soumyajit and his friend Neeladri Ghosh in the 14th metropolitan magistrate court at Miyapur, Cyberabad.

According to the police report, Neeladri Ghosh along with his classmates Sudip Ghosh, Uttiya Mukherjee, Souran Myti, Arpan Mujender and Pushpender Mondal went for a late night party at Soumyajit Basu's Bachupalli residence on February 28 this year. After partying till 3 am in the morning, Soumyajit went to drop Neeladri, Souran, Uttiya and Sudip Ghosh in his car and he accidentally hit a tree at Pragati Nagar at KBHB Colony resulting in the death of Sudip and Uttiya on the spot. Other occupants of the car suffered injuries.

Soumyajit prevailed upon Neeladri to tell cops that it was Sudip who was driving the car when the accident occurred. However, Sudip's parents contested this saying that their son did not even know how to drive a car.

Cyberabad police told the CJ that a chargesheet has been filed against Soumyajit and Neeladri for trying to erase the evidence and mislead the police in the case.

The bench of chief justice Kalyan Jyoti Sengupta and justice P V Sanjay Kumar posted the case to next week for hearing.
Read More...

'Rule of Law is in safe hands'

By Express News Service - KOCHI

Supreme Court Judges Justice Jasti Chelameshwar and Justice Kurian Joseph sharing a word during the NJA South Zone Judicial Conference on ‘Role of Courts in Upholding Rule of Law’ at the High Court Auditorium on Sunday. HC Chief Justice Manjula Chellur and Justice P R Ramachandran Menon are also seen | EXPRESS
Supreme Court Judges Justice Jasti Chelameshwar and Justice Kurian Joseph sharing a word during the NJA South Zone Judicial Conference on ‘Role of Courts in Upholding Rule of Law’ at the High Court Auditorium on Sunday. HC Chief Justice Manjula Chellur and Justice P R Ramachandran Menon are also seen | EXPRESS



Though the country follows a democratic set-up where the citizens have all freedom, the rule of law is never compromised. The public need not worry as the rule of law is in safe hands, Supreme Court Justice Jasti Chelameswar has said.
He was speaking at the valedictory function of the National Judicial Academy (NJA) South Zone Judicial Conference  on the ‘Role of Courts in Upholding the Rule of Law’ on Sunday. Kerala High Court Chief Justice Manjula Chellur presided over the function.
“The government comes to power through the votes of the majority. Despite boasting of a democratic set-up and one of the largest armed forces in the world, the governance in the country is based on well laid-out laws and regulations,” Chelamsewar said.
Supreme Court Justice Kurian Joseph spoke about the need for judges to respect the rights of the public.  “The courts play an important role in strengthening the trust of the public in a country where the constitution is the backbone of governance,” he said.
“If the trust of the public is to be strengthened, the judges need to remember to  respect the rights of the people. When the courts ensure that the rights of the citizens are upheld, the trust of the people will automatically increase,” Justice Joseph said.
He added that the judges should deliver judgements based on the merits of the judicial system. Also, they must remember that they are not exempt from the rulings of the court. “The courts also play an important role in upholding the principle of democracy in the land. The verdicts should be a pointer to the appropriate conduct of the citizens and prove useful for the betterment of the society,” Justice Joseph said.
Chief Justice of the Kerala High Court Justice Manjulla Chellur, Justice K T Sankaran, Justice P R Ramachandra Menon and Dr Balram Gupta, Director, National Judicial Academy, were also present at the function.
Former Supreme Court Justice K T Thomas, Justice S B Sinha, Justice P K Balasubramanian, Chief Justice of Andhra Pradesh High Court Kalyan Jyothi Sengupta and other members of the judiciary from Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Kerala were present on the occasion.
The regional conference was organised by the National Judicial Academy, in association with the High Courts of various states and the respective State Judicial Academies, with the objective of creating a mechanism to help develop a system of uniformity in understanding the legal principles and judicial structure throughout the country, with a view to promote best practices in a uniform manner.
The proposed theme on the role of courts in the rule of law was conceived for the seminar with an objective to inculcate an understanding of the Constitutional underpinnings of the rule of law in the district judiciary, and promote its application for fair administration of justice.


Read More...

Gujarat assembly passes new lokayukta bill for the 2nd time



Source: TOI


GANDHINAGAR: In the continuing tug of war between Narendra Modi government and the Governor, the state assembly on Tuesday passed the Gujarat Lokayukta Ayog Bill 2013 for a second time without incorporating any major changes sought by Raj Bhavan, setting the stage for a fresh confrontation. 

Governor Kamla Beniwal had on September 3 returned the bill, passed by the assembly on April 2, to the government for reconsideration, dubbing the legislation as "complete mockery of the judicial process and detrimental to the interests of public welfare". 

The contentious new Bill seeks to establish the primacy of the Chief Minister and the government in the appointment of anti-corruption watchdog. 

The Bill, piloted by finance minister Nitin Patel, was passed by the House amid protest by the lone Opposition MLA present-- Keshubhai Patel of Gujarat Parivartan Party-- who demanded it be sent to the Standing Committee. The MLAs of main Opposition Congress and NCP were yesterday suspended for two days for creating unruly scenes. 

In the existing Gujarat Lokayukta Act 1986, the power of selection of Lokayukta is vested in the governor and the chief justice of the high court. The new bill provides for appointment of the lokayukta by a six-member committee headed the chief minister. 

The Bill passed today incorporated two minor changes from its earlier version including one pertaining to the definition of the governor. The other was deleting words 'substantive capacity' from section 3 sub section five of the bill. 

The sub-section five of section 3 of the previous Bill said, "The lokayukta shall be a person who is or has been a judge of Supreme Court of India or Chief Justice of a high court in a substantive capacity". 

The Modi government and Governor Beniwal have been at loggerheads on the issue of appointment of lokayukta ever since she appointed Justice (Retd) R A Mehta to the post on August 25, 2011 bypassing the government, triggering a prolonged legal battle. 

Though her decision was upheld by the high court and Supreme Court, the post is still lying vacant in the state as Mehta refused to take charge.
Read More...